Each observer recognises the illusion separately

The same Phantom Shape has detection target 2. At their first meaningful view, the Guide privately compares each observer’s Observation Readiness with 2.

1. The image’s detection target is 2. Compare each observer separately with the same image.
2. Observer A has Observation Readiness 3. Three is higher than two, so A knows it is an illusion and can see through it.
3. Observer B has Observation Readiness 1. One is not higher than two, so B does not recognise it as an illusion yet. B is not compelled to trust it.
4. A’s warning is communication only. It can give B a reason to inspect; it does not automatically change B’s perception.
5. If B chooses to inspect, B pays for a Major Observation Action: 1 Action Die and any legal Boost. A final total above 2 reveals the illusion to B. A tie or lower gives B no new information.

Result: A’s recognition and warning do not automatically reveal the illusion to B.

• A failed inspection cannot be repeated on the same evidence. A new clue or previously hidden view may permit another attempt.
• Physical contact reveals the lack of substance to the toucher without a detection roll. Pay movement or action costs normally.
• Recognition does not end the spell or reveal it to everyone. The image supplies no physical cover or force.
• Veiled Face uses this detection procedure with its own detection target.